About Andrew

Attorney, Broker, and Your Advocate

15 years helping Greater Boston buyers and sellers, with legal training behind every deal.

Hello, I'm Andrew.
Save Contact

Hello, I'm Andrew.

I'm Andrew McKinney, a real estate broker with Donnelly + Co., a full-service office in Boston's Back Bay. I'm also a licensed attorney. Over the past 15 years I've helped clients complete more than $400 million in real estate transactions across Greater Boston, and I bring a skill set most agents don't have.

I started my career in law. I worked as a litigation paralegal and then as a litigation attorney at Melick, Porter & Shea and at Murphy & Riley. I handled general litigation, insurance defense and professional liability matters. My clients ranged from small start-ups to large insurance companies, and my work was resolving lawsuits and business problems in their favor. I was admitted to the Massachusetts Bar in 2005 and the U.S. Federal Bar in 2006. I also earned an MBA from Suffolk University's Sawyer School of Management, along with my JD from Suffolk University Law School. Before that, I studied Philosophy and Legal Studies at Wheaton College.

In 2009 I moved into residential real estate as an associate broker at Buyers Brokers Only, LLC. For more than a decade I worked there as an exclusive buyer's agent while the firm grew into one of the region's largest exclusive buyer agencies. That experience taught me how to negotiate on the client's side of the table, every time. Since 2020 I've represented buyers, sellers and investors in every market segment, including first-time buyers, move-up buyers, downsizers and luxury clients.

My work centers on Boston, and it reaches Brookline, Cambridge, Newton, Wellesley, Lexington, Needham, Arlington, Waltham, Medford, Dedham, Westwood and Natick. I explain contracts in plain English, I give honest advice, and I watch out for your interests at every step.

Outside of work, I'm a former competitive tennis player and instructor, and I still love health and fitness. I'd love to help you with your next move.

Andrew McKinney

Client-First, Always

Your goals drive every decision. I advocate for you, not for closing a deal at any cost.

Protection Through Precision

My legal training means I read the fine print carefully so nothing surprises you later.

Honest, Clear Advice

I give straightforward answers in plain language, even when they're not what you hoped to hear.

Skilled Negotiation

Years of litigation and dispute resolution help me secure strong terms for buyers and sellers.

Andrew's sales record

Andrew McKinney has closed 45 sales since Nov 2024 (17 as the listing agent, 1 as co-listing agent, 29 representing buyers, 2 on both sides), including in Boston, Quincy and Arlington, at prices from $325K to $2.7M.

Property at 905 Riverside Dr, Methuen, MA 01844
1 / 35
Sold

$560,000

Listed at $535,000

905 Riverside Dr, Methuen, MA 01844

3 bds
|
2 ba
|
1296 sqft
MLS® 73563097Single Family Residence
Donnelly + Co. - Andrew M. Mckinney
Property at 7 Fox St #1, Boston, MA 02122
1 / 24
Sold

$645,000

Listed at $675,000

7 Fox St #1, Boston, MA 02122

3 bds
|
2 ba
|
1450 sqft
MLS® 73405249Condominium
Donnelly + Co. - Andrew M. Mckinney
Property at 20 Wilbur St, Weymouth, MA 02190
1 / 37
Sold

$740,000

Listed at $725,000

20 Wilbur St, Weymouth, MA 02190

4 bds
|
1.5 ba
|
1920 sqft
MLS® 73461175Single Family Residence
Donnelly + Co. - Andrew M. Mckinney
Property at 200 Falls Blvd #G110, Quincy, MA 02169
1 / 25
Sold

$365,000

200 Falls Blvd #G110, Quincy, MA 02169

1 bds
|
1.5 ba
|
752 sqft
MLS® 73430049Condominium
Donnelly + Co. - Andrew M. Mckinney

Source: MLS PIN closed sales, Nov 2024–Nov 2026.

What clients say about Andrew

5.0 out of 5 from 71 Google reviews · Read them on Google

Andrew helped me purchase my first home back in 2015 and when I decided to start renting that space out, Andrew was who I called to list it. He and his team have now helped me through multiple rounds of rental listings in a changing Boston market and have gotten great results every time. They consistently go above and beyond to get the best outcome for their clients and are informed, transparent, and responsive.
Chris Ceglio · on Google · Jun 2026
My family and I were relocating to Boston from out of state, and Andrew was instrumental in helping us secure a great unit in Beacon Hill. Highly recommend!
Andrew McCoy · on Google · May 2026
My family has worked with Andrew on multiple transactions and would highly recommend! He is very knowledgeable and understands the market. His recommendations were all spot on and the folks he introduced us to during the process were also of equal caliber.
Jihyeok Lim · on Google · Jan 2026
Andrew was the listing agent on our home purchase. He and Dimitrios were extremely communicative, professional, and helpful throughout the whole process!
Jeremy Bare · on Google · Jan 2026
Andrew did a fantastic job guiding us through our first home search and purchase. He's got a great eye for detail when touring houses and finds things that could be potential issues. He gave great advice regarding offers and negotiation, and he was also mindful of our budget and other requirements when suggesting places to check out. His prior legal experience also helped out a lot when going through P&S and closing. I felt Andrew did an excellent job representing our best interests and made sure we got the best outcome possible. I'd gladly recommend Andrew to anyone looking to buy a house in the area.
Matan Silver · on Google · Nov 2025

Towns Andrew serves

Selling your home with Andrew

What's my home worth?

Get a valuation for your home. Your request goes straight to Andrew.

Get my home value

Ready to start your journey?

Whether you are looking to buy, sell, or simply want to understand the market better, I'd love to chat.